Sweet Cicely — or Josiah Allen as a Politician — Inside the Classic

(9 User reviews)   2316
Holley, Marietta, 1836-1926 Project Gutenberg 2005 Not confirmed
Women -- Suffrage -- Fiction; Temperance and religion -- Fiction; Methodist Church (U.S.) -- Fiction Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 93,149
Reading time 405 min
Text sections 12

Before opening Sweet Cicely — or Josiah Allen as a Politician — Inside the Classic, the edition data offers a quick orientation: 93,149 words, 6 hr 45 min estimated reading time, and 12 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 18.6 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Women -- Suffrage -- Fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Marietta Holley's comic novel uses the voice of Samantha Allen to argue for women's suffrage and temperance, blending domestic humor with political allegory as she confronts a U.S. President and James G. Blaine over the Whiskey Ring.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.9/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

the middle of winter, along in the forenoon, that Josiah Allen was telegrafted to, unexpected. His niece Cicely and her little boy was goin' to pass through Jonesville the next day on her way to visit her aunt Mary (aunt on her mother's side), and she would stop off, and make us a short visit if convenient.

We wuz both tickled, highly tickled; and Josiah, before he had read the telegraf ten minutes, was out killin' a hen. The plumpest one in the flock was the order I give; and I wus a beginnin' to make a fuss, and cook up for her.

We loved her jest about as well as we did Tirzah Ann. Sweet Cicely was what we used to call her when she was a girl. Sweet Cicely is a plant that has a pretty white posy. And our niece Cicely was prettier and purer and sweeter than any posy that ever grew: so we thought then, and so we think still.

Her mother was my companion's sister,--one of a pair of twins, Mary and Maria, that thought the world of each other, as twins will. Their mother died when they wus both of 'em babies; and they wus adopted by a rich aunt, who brought 'em up elegant, and likely too: that I will say for her, if she wus a 'Piscopal, and I a Methodist. I am both liberal and truthful--very.

Maria wus Cicely's ma, and she wus left a widow when she wus a young woman; and Cicely wus her only child. And the two wus bound up in each other as I never see a mother and daughter in my life before or sense.

The third year after Josiah and me wus married, Maria wusn't well, and the doctor ordered her out into the country for her health; and she and little Cicely spent the hull of that summer with us. Cicely wus about ten; and how we did love that girl! Her mother couldn't bear to have her out of her sight; and I declare, we all of us wus jest about as bad. And from that time they used to spend most all of their summers in Jonesville. The air agreed with 'em, and so did I: we never had a word of trouble. And we used to visit them quite a good deal in the winter season: they lived in the city.

Wall, as Cicely got to be a young girl, I used often to set and look at her, and wonder if the Lord could have made a prettier, sweeter girl if he had tried to. She looked to me jest perfect, and so she did to Josiah.

And she knew so much, too, and wus so womanly and quiet and deep. I s'pose it wus bein' always with her mother that made her seem older and more thoughtful than girls usially are. It seemed as if her great dark eyes wus full of wisdom beyend--fur beyend--her years, and sweetness too. Never wus there any sweeter eyes under the heavens than those of our niece Cicely.

She wus very fair and pale, you would think at first; but, when you would come to look closer, you would see there was nothing sickly in her complexion, only it was very white and smooth,--a good deal like the pure white leaves of the posy Sweet Cicely. She had a gentle, tender mouth, rose-pink; and her cheeks wuz, when she would get rousted up and excited about any thing; and then it would all sort o' die out again into that pure white. And over all her face, as sweet and womanly as it was, there was a look of power, somehow, a look of strength, as if she would venture much, dare much, for them she loved. She had the gift, not always a happy one, of loving,--a strength of devotion that always has for its companion-trait a gift of endurance, of martyrdom if necessary.

She would give all, dare all, endure all, for them she loved. You could see that in her face before you had been with her long enough to see it in her life.

Her hair wus a soft, pretty brown, about the color of her eyes. And she wus a little body, slender, and sort o' plump too; and her arms and hands and neck wus soft and white as snow almost.

Yes, we loved Cicely: and no one could blame us, or wonder at us for callin' her after the posy Sweet Cicely; for she wus prettier than any posy that ever blew, enough sight.

Wall, she had always said she couldn't live if her mother died.

But she did, poor little creeter! she did.

Maria died when Cicely wus about eighteen. She had always been delicate, and couldn't live no longer: so she died. And Josiah and me went right after the poor child, and brought her home with us.

She lived, Cicely did, because she wus young, and couldn't die. And Josiah and me wus dretful good to her; and many's the nights that I have gone into her room when I'd hear her cryin' way along in the night; many's the times I have gone in, and took her in my arms, and held her there, and cried with her, and soothed her, and got her to sleep, and held her in my arms like a baby till mornin'. Wall, she lived with us most a year that time; and it wus about two years after, while she wus to some of her father's folks'es (they wus very rich), that she met the young man she married,--Paul Slide.

He wus a handsome young man, well-behaved, only he would drink a little once in a while: he'd got into the habit at college, where his mate wus wild, and had his turns. But he wus very pretty in his manners, Paul was,--polite, good-natured, generous-dispositioned,--and very rich.

And as to his looks, there wuzn't no earthly fault to find with him, only jest his chin. And I told Josiah, that how Cicely could marry a man with such a chin wus a mystery to me.

And Josiah said, “What is the matter with his chin?”

And I says, “Why, it jest sets right back from his mouth: he hain't got no chin at all hardly,” says I. “The place where his chin ort to be is nothin' but a holler place all filled up with irresolution and weakness. And I believe Cicely will see trouble with that chin.”

And then--I well remember it, for it was the very first time after marriage, and so, of course, the very first time in our two lives--Josiah called me a fool, a “dumb fool,” or jest the same as called me so. He says, “I wouldn't be a dumb fool if I was in your place.”

I felt worked up. But, like warriors on a battle-field, I grew stronger for the fray; and the fray didn't scare me none.

But I says, “You'll see if you live, Josiah Allen”; and he did.

But, as I said, I didn't see how Cicely ever fell in love with a man with such a chin. But, as I learned afterwards, she fell in love with him under a fur collar. It wus on a slay-ride. And he wuz very handsome from his mouth up, very: his mouth wuz ruther weak. It wus a case of love at first sight, which I believe in considerable; and she couldn't help lovin' him, women are so queer.

I had always said that when Cicely did love, it would go hard with her. Many's the offers she'd had, but didn't care for 'em. But I knew, with her temperament and nater, that love, if it did come to her, would come to stay, and it would come hard and voyalent. And so it did.

She worshipped him, as I said at first, under a fur collar. And then, when a woman once gets to lovin' a man as she did, why, she can't help herself, chin or no chin. When a woman has once throwed herself in front of her idol, it hain't so much matter whether it is stuffed full of gold, or holler: it hain't so much matter _what_ they be, I think. Curius, hain't it?

It hain't the easiest thing in the world for such a woman as Cicely to love, but it is a good deal easier for her than to unlove, as she found out afterwards. For twice before her marriage she saw him out of his head with liquor; and it wus my advice to her, to give him up.

And she tried to unlove him, tried to give him up.

But, good land! she might jest as well have took a piece of her own heart out, as to take out of it her love for him: it had become a part of her. And he told her she could save him, her influence could redeem him, and it wus the only thing that could save him.

And Cicely couldn't stand such talk, of course; and she believed him--believed that she could love him so well, throw her influence so around him, as to hold him back from any evil course.

It is a beautiful hope, the very beautifulest and divinest piece of folly a woman can commit. Beautiful enough in the sublime martyrdom of the idee, to make angels smile; and vain enough, and foolish enough in its utter uselessness, to make sinners weep. It can't be done--not in 98 cases out of a 100 at least.

Why, if a man hain't got love enough for a woman when he is tryin' to win her affection,--when he is on probation, as you may say,--to stop and turn round in his downward course, how can she expect he will after he has got her, and has let down his watch, so to speak?

But she loved him. And when I warned her with tears in my eyes, warned her that mebby it wus more than her own safety and happiness that wus imperilled, I could see by the look in her eyes, though she didn't say much, that it wusn't no use for me to talk; for she wus one of the constant natures that can't wobble round. And though I don't like wobblin', still I do honestly believe that the wobblers are happier than them that can't wobble.

I could see jest how it wuz, and I couldn't bear to have her blamed. And I would tell folks,--some of the relations on her mother's side,--when they would say, “What a fool she wus to have him!”--I'd say to 'em, “Wall, when a woman sees the man she loves goin' down to ruination, and tries to unlove him, she'll find out jest how much harder it is to unlove him than to love him in the first place: they'll find out it is a tough job to tackle.”

I said this to blamers of Cicely (relatives, the best blamers you can find anywhere). But, at the same time, it would have been my way, when he had come a courtin' me so far gone with liquor that he could hardly stand up--why, I should have told him plain, that I wouldn't try to set myself up as a rival to alcohol, and he might pay to that his attentions exclusively hereafter.

But she didn't. And he promised sacred to abstain, and could, and did, for most a year; and she married him.

But, jest before the marriage, I got so rousted up a thinkin' about what I had heard of him at college,--and I studied on his picture, which she had sent me, took sideways too, and I could see plain (why, he hadn't no chin at all, as you may say; and his lips was weak and waverin' as ever lips was, though sort o' amiable and fascinating),--and I got to forebodin' so about that chin, and my love for her wus a hunchin' me up so all the time, that I went to see her on a short tower, to beset her on the subject. But, good land! I might have saved my breath, I might have saved my tower.

I cried, and she cried too. And I says to her before I thought,--

“He'll be the ruin of you, Cicely.”

And she says, “I would rather be beaten by his hand, than to be crowned by another. Why, I love him, aunt Samantha.”

You see, that meant a awful sight to her. And as she looked at me so earnest and solemn, with tears in them pretty brown eyes, there wus in her look all that that word could possibly mean to any soul.

But I cried into my white linen handkerchief, and couldn't help it, and couldn't help sayin', as I see that look,--

“Cicely, I am afraid he will break your heart--kill you”--

“Why, I am not afraid to die when I am with him. I am afraid of nothing--of life, or death, or eternity.”

Well, I see my talk was no use. I see she'd have him, chin or no chin. If I could have taken her up in my arms, and run away with her then and there, how much misery I could have saved her from! But I couldn't: I had the rheumatiz. And I had to give up, and go home disappointed, but carryin' this thought home with me on my tower,--that I had done my duty by our sweet Cicely, and could do no more.

As I said, he promised firm to give up drinking. But, good land! what could you expect from that chin? That chin couldn't stand temptation if it came in his way. At the same time, his love for Cicely was such, and his good heart and his natural gentlemanly intuitions was such, that, if he could have been kep' out of the way of temptation, he would have been all right.

If there hadn't been drinking-saloons right in front of that chin, if it could have walked along the road without runnin' right into 'em, it would have got along. That chin, and them waverin'-lookin', amiable lips, wouldn't have stirred a step out of their ways to get ruined and disgraced: they wouldn't have took the trouble to.

And for a year or so he and the chin kep' out of the way of temptation, or ruther temptation kep' out of their way; and Cicely was happy,--radiently happy, as only such a nature as hern can be. Her face looked like a mornin' in June, it wus so bright, and glowing with joy and happy love.

I visited her, stayed 3 days and 2 nights with her; and I almost forgot to forebode about the lower part of his face, I found 'em so happy and prosperous and likely.

Paul wus very rich. He wus the only child: and his pa left 2 thirds of his property to him, and the other third to his ma, which wus more than she could ever use while she wus alive; and at her death it wus to go to Paul and his heirs.

They owned most all of the village they lived in. His pa had owned the township the village was built on, and had built most all the village himself, and rented the buildings. He owned a big manufactory there, and the buildings rented high.

Wall, it wus in the second year of their marriage that that old college chumb--(and I wish he had been chumbed by a pole, before he had ever gone there). He had lost his property, and come down in the world, and had to work for a livin'; moved into that village, and opened a drinking-saloon and billiard-room.

He had been Paul's most intimate friend at college, and his evil genius, so his mother said. But he was bright, witty, generous in a way, unprincipled, dissipated. And he wanted Paul's company, and he wanted Paul's money; and he had a chin himself, and knew how to manage them that hadn't any.

Wall, Cicely and his mother tried to keep Paul from that bad influence. But he said it would look shabby to not take any notice of a man because he wus down in the world. He wouldn't have much to do with him, but it wouldn't do to not notice him at all. How curius, that out of good comes bad, and out of bad, good. That was a good-natured idee of Paul's if he had had a chin that could have held up his principle; but he didn't.

So he gradually fell under the old influence again. He didn't mean to. He hadn't no idee of doin' so when he begun. It was the chin.

He begun to drink hard, spent his nights in the saloon, gambled,--slipped right down the old, smooth track worn by millions of jest such weak feet, towards ruin. And Cicely couldn't hold him back after he had got to slippin': her arms wuzn't strong enough.

She went to the saloon-keeper, and cried, and begged of him not to sell her husband any more liquor. He was very polite to her, very courteous: everybody was to Cicely. But in a polite way he told her that Paul wus his best customer, and he shouldn't offend him by refusing to sell him liquor. She knelt at his feet, I hearn,--her little, tender limbs on that rough floor before that evil man,--and wept, and said,--

“For the sake of her boy, wouldn't he have mercy on the boy's father.”

But in a gentle way he gave her to understand that he shouldn't make no change.

And he told her, speakin' in a dretful courteous way, “that he had the law on his side: he had a license, and he should keep right on as he was doing.”

And so what could Cicely do? And time went on, carryin' Paul further and further down the road that has but one ending. Lower and lower he sunk, carryin' her heart, her happiness, her life, down with him.

And they said one cold night Paul didn't come home at all, and Cicely and his mother wus half crazy; and they wus too proud, to the last, to tell the servants more than they could help: so, when it got to be most mornin', them two delicate women started out through the deep snow, to try to find him, tremblin' at every little heap of snow that wus tumbled up in the path in front of 'em; tremblin' and sick at heart with the agony and dread that wus rackin' their souls, as they would look over the cold fields of snow stretching on each side of the road, and thinkin' how that face would look if it wus lying there staring with lifeless eyes up towards the cold moonlight,--the face they had kissed, the face they had loved,--and thinkin', too, that the change that had come to it--was comin' to it all the time--was more cruel and hopeless than the change of death.

So they went on, clear to the saloon; and there they found him,--there he lay, perfectly stupid, and dead with liquor.

And they both, the broken-hearted mother and the broken-hearted wife, with the tears running down their white cheeks, besought the saloon-keeper to let him alone from that night.

The mother says, “Paul is so good, that if you did not tempt him, entice him here, he would, out of pity to us, stop his evil ways.”

And the saloon-keeper was jest as polite as any man wus ever seen to be,--took his hat off while he told 'em, so I hearn, “that he couldn't go against his own interests: if Paul chose to spend his money there, he should take it.”

“Will you break our hearts?” cried the mother.

“Will you ruin my husband, the father of my boy?” sobbed out Cicely, her big, sorrowful eyes lookin' right through his soul--if he _had_ a soul.

And then the man, in a pleasant tone, reminded 'em,--

“That it wuzn't him that wus a doin' this. It wus the law: if they wanted things changed, they must look further than him. He had a license. The great Government of the United States had sold him, for a few dollars, the right to do just what he was doing. The law, and all the respectability that the laws of our great and glorious Republic can give, bore him out in all his acts. The law was responsible for all the consequenses of his acts: the men were responsible who voted for license--it was not him.”

Marietta Holley, writing as "Josiah Allen's Wife," opens Sweet Cicely — or Josiah Allen as a Politician with a preface that frames the book as a favored "thought-child" among her works, a claim she defends to her husband Josiah with characteristic bluntness: "I did it to keep from lyin'." This direct, colloquial voice—Samantha Allen's—carries the entire narrative, blending domestic comedy with pointed political argument. The catalog subjects list women's suffrage, temperance, and Methodist religion, but the excerpts reveal a more specific focus: the Whiskey Ring, a real political scandal of the 1880s, and Samantha's confrontations with national figures. The dedication to "sad-eyed mothers" signals the book's central concern: the threat of alcohol to young men, embodied in the titular Cicely, a mother anxious about her son's future. Holley's method is to embed serious reform arguments within Samantha's folksy, relentless speechifying, often directed at powerful men who cannot get a word in edgewise.

Samantha's Vernacular as Political Weapon

Samantha Allen's dialect—full of dropped g's, colloquial spellings like "hull" and "agin," and homespun metaphors—is not mere local color but the engine of the book's satire. Her husband Josiah serves as a foil, often retreating to the barn when argument fails. In the excerpt, Samantha lectures a U.S. President (unnamed but clearly Chester A. Arthur) on the Whiskey Ring, using the plight of a poor woman named Dorlesky to illustrate national corruption. She shifts seamlessly from domestic detail ("Dorlesky was middlin' disagreeable, and very humbly") to fiscal analysis: "Every penny they give, is money right out of the people's pockets." The President's polite evasions—"The laws of the United States are such, that I can't interfere"—are no match for her relentless logic. Holley uses Samantha's unpolished speech to expose the polished evasions of power, making the vernacular a tool of moral clarity.

The Whiskey Ring as National Allegory

The catalog subject "temperance and religion" might suggest a simple moral tale, but the excerpts show Holley engaging directly with the Whiskey Ring scandal, a network of distillers and politicians that defrauded the U.S. government of millions in the 1870s. Samantha describes the ring as a literal noose around the nation: "allowin' a ring to be put round the United States, and let a lot of whiskey-dealers lead her round." She personifies Columbia as a drunken woman, a shocking image for contemporary readers. The argument is economic as well as moral: she calculates the hidden costs of liquor revenue—almshouses, jails, graves—to refute the claim that the trade benefits the Treasury. Holley does not stop at generalities; she names James G. Blaine, the powerful Republican senator, as the man to whom Samantha should take Dorlesky's case. This specificity grounds the novel in actual political battles, making it a roman à clef of the Gilded Age.

The Limits of the Excerpts: Cicely and the Plot

Despite the title, the excerpts reveal almost nothing about the character Sweet Cicely herself. The dedication addresses "sad-eyed mothers" looking "across the cradle of their boys into the great world of temptation," and the list of illustrations includes scenes like "Cicely in the Saloon" and "Cicely and the Boy," suggesting she is a mother whose son is endangered by drink. But the surviving text focuses overwhelmingly on Samantha's political monologues. The preface hints that Cicely is a "thought-child"—a fictional creation Holley loves best—but the excerpts do not show her in action. Readers should expect a frame story in which Cicely's personal struggle motivates Samantha's crusade, but the bulk of the book, based on these passages, is given over to Samantha's comic and fervent debates with politicians. The catalog subjects accurately reflect the book's concerns, but the emotional core implied by the title may be more present in the full text than in these selections.

Readers approaching Sweet Cicely should be prepared for a hybrid work: part domestic comedy in the tradition of Holley's earlier Samantha books, part political tract aimed at the Whiskey Ring and the temperance movement. The humor lies in Samantha's unshakeable confidence and her ability to reduce powerful men to silence, but the arguments are earnest and detailed. The excerpts suggest that the novel's structure is episodic, with Samantha traveling to Washington to confront officials, rather than following a single plot. Those interested in 19th-century women's political writing, dialect literature, or the intersection of religion and reform will find this a rich, if occasionally digressive, text.

I kept thinking about Samantha Allen long after Sweet Cicely—how she could scold a president with a pie in one hand and quiet dignity in the other. That same voice found me again in Mary Minds Her Business — Inside the Classic. It’s a gentler sort of stubbornness, maybe, but familiar. Sometimes a woman’s humor carries more sense than any speech, and I find myself smiling at that thought still.

Victoria Rodriguez
1 week ago

Carter Miller
1 week ago

Avery Scott
3 weeks ago

Mila Robinson
3 weeks ago

Theodore Hernandez
1 month ago

5
5 out of 5 (9 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
  • ...
    Rachel Riggs - 3 weeks ago
    While the concept of a woman in politics is interesting, the execution in 'Sweet Cicely' is lacking. The writing is overly simplistic, and the satire is heavy-handed. The character of Josiah Allen is charming at first but becomes one-dimensional. The plot drags in places, and the political commentary feels dated. A mediocre read that doesn't offer much depth.

  • ...
    Kara Thomas - 2 weeks ago
    A charming and humorous tale with a strong female lead, Josiah Allen, who takes on the political world with wit and wisdom. The audiobook narration is superb, bringing the character to life. The story is both entertaining and insightful, offering a unique perspective on politics and society. I found myself laughing out loud and thoroughly enjoyed every moment.

  • ...
    Adam Nash - 2 weeks ago
    The story is enjoyable and provides a nice glimpse into the era's political landscape. The humor is light and sometimes predictable, but the characters are endearing. However, the plot could have been more intricate, and some chapters felt repetitive. Still, it's a pleasant enough read, especially if you enjoy vintage feminist literature.


Reader reflection

What was your reading experience?

Capture what you thought, learned, and would like to remember.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

How far have you progressed with this book?

2

Was reading this book enjoyable?

3

Would you encourage someone else to read it?

4

How much effort did this book require?

Related eBooks